Grain Tax Change- My Proposal
![Belgium](http://www.erepublik.net/images/flags_png/S/Israel.png)
Justin Moore
I have just introduced this to the congressional debate forums and debate will continue for 24 hours. This is to all domestic grain producers calling for a higher import rate to protect you further. Some do not think a higher import tax would be good. I personally do.
Keep in mind that these views and ideas are expressed by me as an Individual and not as a government as a whole. Debate will continue and private and not in public for 24 hours and then we will go from there depending on the nature of the debate. This is another Transparency effort on my part.
This is the initial post.
I hereby propose the following correction and voting session on the Grain Tax rates. There has been much heated debate regarding grain tax over the past month and I personally think this proposal would help to correct the issue going forward. Let’s engage in friendly debate for 24 hours before we move to vote. I think it is worthy of our time and will encourage good debate on the issue that was left unresolved previously.
Income Tax- 2% income tax- The government needs to make some money, lowering income tax across the board will not allow the government to pay for the things the people need. This proposal only raises the income tax 1% which is not much, but every NIS counts, this will allow companies to continue to operate with enough profit to carry on.
Import Tax- 35%- This will raise the import tax from 20% back up to 35%. This will help stem the flow of foreign grain. The grain market has been deflated and prices have fallen in regards to grain over the last month as a whole. Cheap grain means cheap food for cheap people. Higher grain means higher food, for cheap people, for a while at least. If domestic grain companies can actually operate with a small profit, they will in turn be able to pay their employees more, creating an economic base for the food industry to build off of over time. If grain employees are making more, then they can afford to buy the slightly higher food. Our economy is deflated more so than many other nations at this time and I firmly believe that it starts with grain. My initial thought was back up to 50% for import tax but in order to appease resistance from the other side I will settle for proposing 35% in an effort to reach across the Isle.
There are several different arguments and angles with this situation and rightfully so. One argument is that Israel is only a medium grain producing nation. Okay, but we are a small nation with not very many mouths to feed, we should only be supporting ourselves with grain and not others, and same thing with food, these things should be strictly domestic. We must build an economic base off of grain and food, and then focus on other areas of economic concern.
I am not an economist, but I am a person with National pride, and a nation that allows other nations to feed it dominantly is not a wise one. We must make our necessities here with what we have and build a base off of it. We must support our domestic companies. Israel comes first, Imports last in areas where we don’t need them. In areas such as wood and oil and other resources, we have to have imports, and that is where they come in. We had grain, we still have it. Let’s use it and only it.
Comments
Changing income tax from 1% to 2% makes little sense but it's still ok now increasing the import tax isn't the right way to go... at all!
We have to get used to that we will never get a decent land based economy so we should focus on manufacturing products, since land products are cheap we can import (it's no biggy) and export highly quality products, that's what the congressman should focus on.
I'm saying this even when I owned Kosher Foods I bough ever single grain from Israeli companies, but then my idea wasn't to profit from the company.
Btw can you give me a link to the Israeli forum? I lost the links.
sure bud, I understand your argument and its valid to a point. I think we need to focus on a strong manufacturing sector with no or limited imports to create jobs, But a strong grain base wouldnt hurt either.
[shrugs]
You realise that foreign Grain companies will simply pay *no* tax? Just gift the grain to the food company, getting payment by donation - or have the same org own both food and grain companies, so that payment isn't a concern.
Having to many people in grain industry not only impoverish those workers but slows down Israel's economy.
Israel should focus on hight quality products to export and to home consumption as cheaply as possible, so probably a few state companies in the equation.
Since the economic model in eRepublik is so basic and distorted from real life, the best option is a mixed free market with a state owned one.
Not to mention we are living in a deflation period price of products fall so as wages and it's cycle, to break that we should invest in a few organized wars, like the one between US and Ireland.
In conclusion I believe we should only have one grain company (state owned) not for profit but to maintain a certain autonomy from other countries and for the current land workers that don't want to change their skills and still have a fair payment for their work.
So imo the income taxes of every land resource should be put to 100%, the import tax to 1% except for grain at 20%.
While I would support free markets in reality, I think in this case having a higher import tax for grain is a pretty good idea to strengthen local companies for a while
http://erandia.net/tjc/index.php" target="_blank">http://erandia.net/tjc/index.php
Thanks eliberator.