eSocialism and eCommunism
JGutenberg
They say, “Communism is a good idea, but it only works in theory.” I say, “eRepublik is a theoretical game where the efforts of a full days work are represented by the click of the mouse.”
Why eCommunism and eSocialism should be given a chance.
First of all, a more socialist government would be more welcoming to newer players than a traditional capitalistic system.
Having effective and powerful state industries gives all new citizens the opportunity to work at a well paying job that also benefits the Irish state. Despite alleged reform after Connel Rath's excellent article("The Embarrassment of the Irish State Industries"😉
, the only Irish State Industries offering Skill 0 Jobs is Irish state Housing who despite having 11 employees only has two who appear to be actually active, and DoD State Travel which is doing somewhat better with the second best wages by .31 IEP with 3 active workers. However I must admit that it does not even take Socialism to solve these problems.
A more structured government would also mean a better public health care system, which would also be beneficial for new citizens such as myself who are struggling to maintain their wellness while working and training every day in a country where wages are not very high and food is fairly expensive. Now that I have finally reached level 3 Manufacturing, I can start gaining wellness again, but it took me 16 days of wellness loss to get to this point, which I think is screaming for reform.
Instead of taking from the rich and giving to the poor, eCommunism, through higher taxes take from the older, who generally have less need for money, and give to the newer who could always use a leg-up.
Recently in Ireland there has been some talk about bringing new citizens to eIreland. Having a more helpful and supportive government would create a more welcoming and pleasant environment for new Irish citizens.
eCommunism and eSocialism would also give the government a closer control of the Irish economy, something that it is also rather lacking. Ireland’s Gross Domestic Product is 1046.34, the 53d out of 60 eNations, despite having the 37th place population. Both of these numbers are incredibly disheartening and to me scream of reform.
Although I wasn’t born then, I’m sure that some of the older players here remember when the IEP had the lowest Recommended Exchange Rate (RER) in the entire New World,[1] and I’m sure even more would wish to have our economy and currency to return to such a state.
We Irishmen have geniuses (and plenty of Guinness too) among us, and applying such individuals to the right place could give our economy a definite turn for the better.
According to jamesw, having a better economy would also give the UK to attack and activate our MPPs against them, although I would not consider it as its main attraction.
A stronger government would also mean stronger government institutions, including the IDF, which in wake of although apparently empty threats against our nation could always use some support. (And Psst, CPL Useless if you're reading this, there have been at least 14 sign-ups in the IDF enlistment thread since you've last responded...)
The evidence to me is overwhelming. Ireland is in need of change!
--
Discussion is welcome and encouraged, as is of course voting and subscribing. I don’t have a very solid understanding of the eRepublik economics, so please excuse(and private message me about) any misinformation or discrepancies in information so I can correct them immediately.
Please note that I am not trying to start a debate about the merits and demerits of real life communism or socialism, but rather the merits and demerits of eCommunism and eSocialism, which are incredibly different things.
For my next article I intend to do another roleplay piece. Until then, enjoy. 🙂
[1] http://wiki.erepublik.com/index.php/Ireland
Comments
The GDP counters etc are generally bugged.
I like your style though.
The lively hood of a Citizen is often his or her wellness. Housing is the long term answer to any wellness Problem. We are reaching an abortive state, waiting for V2 to launch now, as Hospitals no longer provide Wellness.
@e-Socialism: I like your out look on. It is important to note that Ireland, like much of the New World, has been e-Socialist for nearly it's entire existence. This was due to over production, thus the huge meaningless wars that were made from it. Many governments simply had to put Citizens in public sector jobs, because the world currency at large was in such a mess due to over-production. Now that the new Hospital rules are here we will see economic activity based on citizen skill rather than war as the prime mover of economies.
Ronald Reagan said, "Communism only works in two places. Heaven, where they don't need it, and Hell, where they already have it."
It does not need to be given a chance, because it has already succeeded. The commune programs have shown that eCommunism can work, and I am certain it can continue to do so.
Gruber, if you mean the "State-run" Companies (Public Sector), they only continue to exist through massive Taxation.
On the side of what have been called communes, they take eons to manipulate in a true Communist way. Most do not run by their namesake due to the taxing amount of time required and the limited effect per company.
There is a reason you do not see the Most Experienced Players working in Communes. They have reach such a high skill, that they can "Market" their labor for greater effect on a countries economy than to work in what you term as a Commune.
The commune system most common in Erepublik, which is more like a philanthropy, sucks Money out of a Country leading to deflation.
No, I mean communes such as the Labour communes, or the Russian communes. We have good workers working in these communes, and they achieve equality and fair wages, along with gifts from the commune organization.
Do they get Tax exemptions from the Govt?
They don't so they are not e-Communist, they cannot function indefinitely, and while operating must keep liquidity with monetary donations, or dare I say it sell on the "Free Market".
At best they are private Philanthropies.
Voted+subs
Great article, I agree completely. The Labour party has set up communes in Ireland and are currently active and working for the people. Shoot me a Pm if you wish to get involved.
commies are bad, and socialism is a thief
You get it 🙂
V + S
So in essence eSocialism and eCommunism are not true to RL models having to rely on market sales to support themselves. So in effect they are private "closed" industries. Everyone may agree to work for lower wages to support your fellow workers but you still have to use market economics to support yourselves. That is the way the game is set up by the Admins.
"Now that the new Hospital rules are here we will see economic activity based on citizen skill rather than war as the prime mover of economies."
This is entirely incorrect.
The weapons sector remains the largest sector of any economy, and will continue to be the biggest into V2.
"So in essence eSocialism and eCommunism are not true to RL models having to rely on market sales to support themselves. So in effect they are private "closed" industries. Everyone may agree to work for lower wages to support your fellow workers but you still have to use market economics to support yourselves."
Nope, we don't need to enter the market at all.
We choose to in order to expand our communes.
"We choose to in order to expand our communes."
That is a complete farce and just a fancy way of ignoring the fact that these "communes" would not survive without selling their goods in the appropriate markets. I would suggest that if these "communes" are so full of themselves and their abilities, they should cease to sell on the open market and cut themselves off. Then truly they would have to admit that they need the markets to make money to run these crackpot institutions just like everyone else.
Oh lol, and a wink to Eamon 😉
But I really wonder does it actually matter a toss what we call the ideology??
Does it?
Noobs and e-older players have hugely different skills, needs and requirements in terms of labour supply.
For example, I am happy to work for friends. Even well below market rates for my skill, if we both benefit in some way that's mutually acceptable.
I have worked for guns alone...paid in hardware and pence.
I have been part of a military machine that provides for my every (and I mean every) e-need, and pays me peanuts...and it was the most fulfilling period of my e-life.
I've worked for stateco's, 'cause they needed it.
I've remained unemployed so I could vagabond around, fighting.
Many people I know here make decisions on a cyclical basis as to how they will offer their labour. I honestly don't know anyone who sticks to one ideology, and never wavers..
Once you have control of your e-life, needing government support seems a ridiculous crutch to me, and redundant.
And yet we have grossly inefficient statecos for noobs, and always have had, since I was e-born.
So sick of this recurring debate, like groundhog day tbh.
Can't we just care for the noobs, til they can decide for themselves, and stop labelling every goddamn thing in this game?
No?
oh...ok then...
lol.
i've tried twice to leave a comment on this article but game kicked me to home page LOL
i'm tired of writing so i'm trying my last chance with a short comment.
eCommunism is good and keep people active 🙂 if you want to know how it does, please ask me with a PM 🙂
Communism killed my dad.