Our New Government--The First Week's Report Card
![Canada](http://www.erepublik.net/images/flags_png/S/Canada.png)
CSD
It has been a week since the Bruck government took power. Obviously, we cannot expect all of the campaign promises to be fulfilled in that short time. We can review the actions so far to see how successful the government has been.
We have used the campaign platform posted on the eCanada forum [url=” http://ecanada.forumotion.com/election-center-f42/coalition-for-change-cfc-platform-march-2009-t895.htm”] (here) [/url] as the basis for rating.
1. The Military
A. Encourage Canadians to enlist and train as CAF Regulars for deployment with full government-issued supplies when called upon or as National Reserves to support deployed Regulars and help defend Canadian soil in emergencies. This will help ensure consistency and growth in Canada's Military.
Our recent efforts in France would seem to indicate that this is not fully implemented. There are numerous messages on the forums from CAF members requesting supplies that were not delivered.
B. Continue to have the Minister of Defense (MoD) act as administrative supply officer for the CAF and work with the General to supply the CAF as is deemed effective. The CFC believes that a well laid out, top-down chain of command is essential to alliviate bottlenecks in the transfer of supplies and ensure that our soldiers are looked after while they protect our nation.
Like the previous item, the transfer of supplies did not happen, or only happened slowly.
C. Establish a training academy to train recruits at all levels of the CAF. New recruits will gain experience and knowledge into how the CAF operates and how they should go about requesting supplies, who their platoon commander is and how to fight. This will not only improve the quality of soldiers but also increase interest and activity in new members.
There is no indication that any action has been taken on this item.
D. Outfit critical Canadian regions with the highest quality affordable defense systems to ensure the security of our country and our citizens. With these new defense systems, these regions will be more formidable defensive strongholds. The CFC refuses to waste valuable Canadian dollars (CAD) on costly, low quality defense systems in less critical regions.
This campaign promise has been broken. The Bruck government placed a Q1 defense system in Alberta. Obviously, a Q1 system is low quality; Alberta, based on other comments by Bruck, is a “less critical” region.
E. Negotiate with our allies in ATLANTIS for mutual training exersizes and experience in organizing the CAF for mobilization. This will affirm successes of the training academy and will allow the CAF to troubleshoot areas of concern.
This is a promise met. The CAF has deployed to Romania to support our ally in their battle against Indonesia.
F. Institute an elite CAF unit of our highest ranked and strongest soldiers to be supplied more often then regular CAF and Reserves. If managed by the CFC, the CAF and citizens of Canada can rest assured that more damage will be inflicted by our forces than ever before.
Another broken promise: according to the Minister of Defense, there is no plan to create an elite force.
G. Maintain a 100-member-strong fighting force at all times.
Since we already had a 100-member force under the Zanalan administration, we will call this a wash.
H. Give the General of the CAF access to the Canada National Defense organization to better supply CAF members and help alleviate current supply issues by adding another layer of trusted support.
As we saw in promise A & B, this has not met the stated goal.
I. Select Divisional Commanders from within the CAF to watch over and instruct the CAF's new leaders. With the growing CAF many new platoons are required to meet demand. With this many new platoon commanders are also required and being new require another level of Military oversight.
We are not sure that we have seen any movement on this item. Like the training academy, we will wait to see if any action is taken on this.
MILITARY—OVERALL: D+
The CfC made nine promises in the election campaign. In the first week of their mandate, they have seen limited or no success on A, B & H. C & I have not been implemented yet. D & F are broken promises. They have met E & G although G is a promise to maintain what was already in place.
PART 2 - THE ECONOMY
1. Taxes
A. Review taxes and encourage Canadian businesses against foreign imports.
This is a broken promise. The two tax changes that have been passed since Bruck took office have both lowered the Import tax.
B. Encourage Canadian businesses to export to our allies in ATLANTIS and neutral nations.
No action has been taken to encourage an increase of exports
C. Raise the VAT tax to 10% to increase the value of the CAD by removing it from the market while strengthening government accounts.
This is a broken promise. Since the election there have been two tax changes passe😛
weapons and food. In both cases, the VAT was not raised to 10%.
ECONOMY—OVERALL: F
The CfC made three promises in the election campaign. Two of the three have been broken and the third has not received any action.
2. Immigration
A. Continue the Immigration Program and provide means to effectively communicate around the world.
This is a continuation of an existing program.
B. Encourage citizens to volunteer their time to the Minister of Immigration in recruiting. This will help integrate all new immigrants into society.
There has been no action to encourage existing citizens to assist in the Immigration program.
C. Continue to provide our nations citizen fee to registered citizens on the eCanadian forum.
This is a continuation of an existing program.
IMMIGRATION—OVERALL: C
The CfC made three promises in the election campaign. Two of the three were the continuation of existing programs. The third has not been implemented.
PART 3 - HEALTHCARE
1. Reallocate healthcare funding to critical regions since it is essential that the CAF soldiers operate out of regions with high quality hospitals. The CFC refuses to waste valuable CAD on costly, low quality hospitals in less critical regions.
No action has been taken on this item yet.
2. Restructure gifting to concentrate on elite CAF members full time and Regulars twice during battle. This will limit the quickly expanding CAF from enveloping our allocated budget.
As we saw in the military section, this has not been successful.
HEALTH CARE—OVERALL: F
The CfC made two promises in the election campaign. One has not been acted upon, and the other has not worked.
PART 4 - FOREIGN AFFAIRS
1. Commit to cooperating with our allies, militarily, economically and through media support.
There has been cooperation with our allies in military activities. We have not seen any indication economic or media activities have taken place.
2. Continue to aid our allies in military conflict at home and abroad.
Full pass
3. Encourage trade of manufactured and raw materials to ATLANTIS members and neutral nations.
No action has been taken on this item yet.
4. Continue to promote eCanada as a world power by helping to set ATLANTIS protocol and diplomacy in world affairs.
While there have been no reports of our activity within ATLANTIS, we will give Bruck a pass on this item.
FOREIGN AFFAIRS—OVERALL: C+
SUMMARY
Canadians elected the Bruck administration based, in part, on the promises made in the campaign platform. Based on this review of the first week in office, we should all wonder how many of the promises are going to be kept. The report card so far is not promising.
MILITARY—OVERALL: D+
ECONOMY—OVERALL: F
IMMIGRATION—OVERALL: C
HEALTH CARE—OVERALL: F
FOREIGN AFFAIRS—OVERALL: C+
WEEK ONE FINAL GRADE – D+ --
Comments
*Points to The Duncan Reforms*
http://www.erepublik.com/en/article/the-duncan-reforms-752258/1/20
I think given the short time frame, and the global turmoil Canada has progressed better than other nations, and the new government has done it's best to reform in a very short period of time under very trying circumstances.
The Q1 Defense system was only purchased to take all the CAD out of the treasury in case we conquered Pays and then lost it again, so we didn't lose any CAD if it happened again.
Doesn't the CSD still have a few members in Congress who should have caught that whole MAJOR debate and executive order?
As for the points after that one, to be honest I stopped reading because I realized whoever wrote this is unfamiliar with the current activities of the Congress and Cabinet...
Hey, personally the report card is a great idea. I cannot comment if it is a legitimate grade but the thought behind it is great for debate.
About time we had some (to quote an annoying PEACEican) "kickassing" in Canadian congress. Regardless of whether or not I agree with any of the points, I'm glad there is a vocal opposition to the government to keep things honest.
I'm not informed enough to either agree or disagree with all the points stated above. Some points regarding the military do seem to be true. What I can say is that the overall concept, though not original, was well executed.
This is a great idea...
If it comes from a non-partisan news media.
l o l
I just want to point out to anyone reading this report card, that the health care section does not include the 'public' health care. This is for the CAF/ military health care operation.
The public health care is going pretty well. I am still working on getting the word out about the health care so more people will use it. But we have had steady requests so far. Nothing spectacular, but like I said, I just need to get the word out so more people know about it.
Thank you
-Emilio Sanchez, Minister of Health and Social Services
Thanks for the opposition and criticism, but you really need to get that citizen converted to an organization... technically that's muiltying, why should you get off from having to pay the 5 gold.
CSD on following the game rules. Final Grade: F
*Bell Rings*
*Professor Phillips raises his voice*
Remember kids your party presidential platforms are due by this Saturday, and you'll lose marks for late assignments
CSD you just lost my respect- I was hoping for something insightful and critical- Instead the people of Canada got an epic FAIL from CSD. I am truly disappointed.
This is so incredibly partisan and full of BS. I might as well grade something as well.
CSD congressmen grade = F
It would be nice if we had some of your members actually ACTIVE in congress and not just using the party to get 5 gold. If you suspect me of lying, just look at good old Jay Bris! I am yet to see Zanalan take part in ANY congressional discussions since he was ousted either. Inactive PM, inactive congressman. No wonder the CSD is dying...
What a waste.
Gee Roy, I would be more than happy to take part in congressional discussions. Can I count on you to introduce a motion to give me access to the forum? See, until I have access to the discussion I am like the majority of Canadians: I have no view into Congress' activities.
I would certainly appreciate it if you would work to fix this problem.
Since your not a congressmen thats unlikely
That is why we have released two reports of what congress has been up to already, only a week in. Everything we have done has been available for the average citizen to see and read.
How was this written if the CSD cannot view the activities of Cabinet or Congress?
I am confused...
CSD has congressmen still AB maybe they provided the info.
unfortunantly this really seems like a desperate last ditch effort by the CSD to get back on top but it obviously isnt working. its sad for me to see this happen...
You should really have access to things like the Officers Lounge and High Command before you go making assertions about what is and isn't going on.
On a side note, Canadians need to start viewing the CAF as something THEY support, not the other way around. The CAF gives supplies because this is in its own best interest, not because eCanadians are entitled to free supplies.
Try serving your country, instead of asking for a handout.
also, just pointing out, according to the rankings page canada imports exactly 0 gold. therefore i'm thinking that raising the import tax would just be a waste of congresses good time.
Well, I am glad that the CSD took some opposition action, but most of this article is a harsh, misguided criticism. For example, the defense system, as said was a mere technicality: it cost the government nothing. The elite division is also being planned. However, I do think you have a few good points: I wouldn't say Bruck is doing a bad job (I'd rate it very well, in fact) but there have been a lot of promises made by the CEP that went unimplemented.
"G. Maintain a 100-member-strong fighting force at all times.
Since we already had a 100-member force under the Zanalan administration, we will call this a wash."
How much of this 100 member force was active until recently?
"2. Restructure gifting to concentrate on elite CAF members full time and Regulars twice during battle. This will limit the quickly expanding CAF from enveloping our allocated budget.
As we saw in the military section, this has not been successful."
I don't recall gifting of wellness being covered in the military section. I do recall however, discussion and action taken on this matter in the IRC and congress so this has been implemented.
As has been stated in may comments by others, it is nice to see an active opposition. Although, an active opposition should be honest and factful in their claims to be taken as such. To be honest, some of the endeavours taken on by President Bruck and the cabinet so far have been large scale ventures, with some of the not met yet promises being small and easy transitions.
If you look at the progress of the existing government through a percentage of WORK accomplished, I believe myself that they are right on track.
Great Job to all in power right now, you have 100% support of this eCanadian.
raptorfan
I like this format, as it allows the current administration to reply in the same format defending its performance against Campaign promises and also highlighting where evolving events have rendered campaign promises moot and why.
I'm not sure how you can grade any military restructuring in a week. It takes alot longer to build experience and see real progress.
Overall, the government gets an A on effort, almost everything else, EPIC FAIL.
Umm F on the economic changes...
you know Canada is in its most economically prosperous period in its entire history, so if we are not jumping at a chance to tinker with taxes which don't need changing (and I made this very clear to Bruck) then I don't see that as a "failure" of Bruck's administration.
As for encouraging exports, well people aren't stupid they will export if they have the capital and the smarts. Those who don't export especially, in the Diamond and Lumber fields will realize very quickly they should and will get the capital to do so.
In other words, the CFC only failed to consult the person actually determining economic policy.
The CSD has done the exact same thing time and time again, Zanalan wanted to see certain taxes set up and promised it in his platform. I disagreed, explained why and taxes didn't match, was that a failure of Zanalan as a president to go with his Finance Minister?
It makes me glad to see the blood is flowing in Canada
a great idea to grade the govt...
but this article!? Not so well-informed...
Nice ideas, good luck!
Article voted and subscribed!
If you are tired of writing and doing serious political activities, you can read these nice jokes to end this week with a smile on your face: http://www.erepublik.com/en/article/finish-your-week-with-these-nice-jokes--750180/1/20
Have a great weekend!
C. Establish a training academy to train recruits at all levels of the CAF. New recruits will gain experience and knowledge into how the CAF operates and how they should go about requesting supplies, who their platoon commander is and how to fight. This will not only improve the quality of soldiers but also increase interest and activity in new members.
I enlisted but was turned away till I had strength at 4.5... which I do understand, I'm not a very value adding member. But it could be broach if this goal if interpreted to be all inclusive.
Gage: Damn straight on all points!
The idea of a loyal opposition is sweet, but is poorly carried out in this article.
And yeah, since when is the CSD a citizen??
Good point Azzeriath. Can a party be citizen? And is it really a party when it only has two friends? (I'm not sure Admin even counts)
I will fix the CSD. No more of this in the new CSD!
AB IN 03! AB IN 03! AB IN 03!
AB FOR CSD PRES!
This Article is Rated A For Epic Fail.
Its neat to watch this under fold and you can clearly see who is siding with who . I'm not in any government party and I love this report card thing. Shows that Government fails in here as well as in RL . Yes ,Its only a Week but wait and see ...
As for CAF should be like in RL . Give you good PAYING jobs when you join and pay you each day when you QUIT your job to go oversea to fight and provide training , equipment and FOOD . You are giving your time and energy to serve them . Hence why the world military budget is HUGE
"There has been no action to encourage existing citizens to assist in the Immigration program."
If im not mistaken... I was encouraged to assist in the immigration program... 😛
thats Mustache btw
As a congressmen, I can verify some of the claims within this article.