MY Opinion on the Public Discussion
![Philippines](http://www.erepublik.net/images/flags_png/S/United-Kingdom.png)
HazzN
It seems to be the fashionable thing to publish long rants about forum discussions in eRepublik Newspapers at the moment, so I thought I might get in on the fun.
1. I don't care one way or another if the HoL is reformed.
2. It doesn't matter what I think about the HoL reform, because once the proposal is made, West Midlands will be given the chance to debate the subject and vote on it. I shall vote in HoC based on the out come of that discussion.
What is really grinding my gears however, is the way this discussion has taken place. It has been aggressive. It has involved about about 2 pages of debate and 16 pages of flame wars and personal attacks. This is not productive. This is not good for our nation.
The Public Discussion forum was created to allow the Public (as in regular citizens of eUK) to have their say on the proposals that will eventually go through Commons. Everyones opinions are supposed to matter. Every voice is supposed to be heard. That is the whole point.
However, this is not occurring.
What I have seen is:
1. Citizens being told their opinions don't count because they aren't experienced enough.
2. The experienced citizens, who we are supposed to trust to make choices for us, acting like 5 year olds who have had their favourite toy confiscated.
3. Citizens, too scared and intimidated by the discussions to say anything.
This is not beneficial. This sort of behaviour will lead to an end of democracy. If you really wish to be patriotic, the flame wars must end. It is possible to debate politics without getting personal or nasty. The forum used to be a nice place to go for a good discussion. It isn't any more. It makes me sad.
Comments
Hear hear. Voted.
p.s. "Grinding my gears"? Family guy reference? 😛
Well said HazzN, this is what I've been thinking about the whole thing. I've stopped reading anything on the forums that mentions the House of Lords becuase I know it'll just be full of insults. Both sides need to steb back and calm down.
Well said,Voted
"p.s. "Grinding my gears"? Family guy reference? 😛"
Well spotted.
@Peter: Couldn't agree more.
Said well, Voted
Agree, well said, voted
Completely agreed.
Debate is what makes the forums great. Telling people their opinion in wrong and blatantly attacking them because it differs does not.
Completely agreed and well said. Voted
agree and voted, though admitt to my personal part towards the beginning in getting too heated, which i have apologised for.
/tommy.
I agree about what you are saying. I don't know whether I'm right in saying this or not, but the forums tend to feel more like you can say what you want, maybe its that they feel somewhat more relaxed that the actual game, is this only me getting this vibe?
I suppose people just sometimes say stupid things to insult people and disregard the other person's opinion. This is often accompanied by no logical explanation like some strange internet people do who are just a bit stubborn and fixed in their Nerd more posts that you ways.
Lol and after someone reads this they will say ha you can't comment you've only posted once or twice, well to that I say well... shut up n00b
I concur.
Sale Food company QC1 with 1100 Grain, 15 Employee, 56 Items
http://www.erepublik.com/en/company/british-food-foundation-164152
i will resign from erepublik
I agree with what you are saying, once I went on the forum and said gold was hard to get and not one person agreed with me and I don't know how they can't! Now I am too intimidated to write on the forums again so I just write my newsapaper and nothing else.
'Now I am too intimidated to write on the forums again'
Just post, you don't know these people IRL so what have you got to lose even if you make a complete t**t out of yourself?
If you're intimidated by people on an internet forum you need help.
"if you're intimidated by people on an internet forum you need help."
hahahaha epic!!!
Good article, it's a shame that the same old people can't play nice.
*Looks below*
Oh look, another sterling contribution to the discussion. Regardless of how meaningless you think an intimidating atmosphere is, it's the reason why we have such a small number of active forum users compared to "2 clickers", so I would kindly ask you to stop talking a load of crap, kthxbye.
Actually that was kinda harsh, weren't feeling too well yesterday, had the day off school and puked up on myself about 10 mins before posting that so I wasn't in a good mood, sorry 'bout that.
I've never been on the forum(s) but your article made me think of something:
"Winning a pointless argument in a forum is like winning the Special Olympics. Even if you win, your still a retard."
Vote +1
I agree wholeheartedly with you on this HazzN. Voted
well said
some of us eRepublik newbies have been admins in other games