eRepublik economy going down, down, down. Solutions.
![Romania](http://www.erepublik.net/images/flags_png/S/Romania.png)
Alex Craciun
In the last weeks all of you probably noticed that eRepublik ecomony is going down.
It was going down slowly but sure, because of the excess of supply (or overproduction) even before this:
ANNOUNCEMENT
but it went way down the hill after everybody started their own company, supply got ski high, prices dropped 30-40% in just two or three days, salaries followed the trend.
Now the situation got a little better but all the monetary markets are screwed, for example USD got down from 0.022 gold/USD to 0.014 gold/USD, RON got down from 0.020 gold/RON to 0.018 gold/RON.
Something happened, you we will see what when we will analyze a little.
So why all the problem with the supply being bigger than demand?
Two reasons for this, I mean before the change two weeks ago:
1. admins changed the formulas some months ago, increasing the overall production
2. eRepublik medium "age" is getting bigger, this is because we don't have too much "youngsters" and because the "elders" are not retiring to enjoy their well earned pension
Because Plato wants to help the youngsters to be more successful he reduced the 40 gold necessary to create a company to just 20 gold and he also allowed everybody to work in all their companies.
Probably the idea was that everybody would produce their own grain, for their own food company, their own iron, for their own weapons company.
Everybody bought or created a company, I strongly believe that in the first day that this rule was imposed there were at least 10.000 companies activated (bought or created).
So, we had excess of supply before this, now everybody produces even more, so there is a lot more excess.
Because of the real impact, but also because of the panic... prices dropped 30-40%, salaries dropped the same 30-40% with a delay of two or three days and after that all the treasureries of all countries got 30-40% less from taxes (income tax and VAT).
There are speculations, articles in newspapers showing income in companies from a entity called "EREPUBLIK", post of the forum saying the same, that Plato decided to stop all this drop by starting to buy excess products from the markets.
But for these Plato needed lots of money, RONs, USDs, all kinds of money.
He had two options to do that:
1. create gold to buy local money, after that use local money to buy excess goods.
2. create directly local money and use it to buy excess goods.
A week ago you all noticed that all countries started to have problems with their exchange rates, so most probably, if the speculations are true and Plato bought excess products indeed, he used the second option, so he flooded all monetary markets with local money.
Exchange rates were facing at least two problems now:
1. a lot less gold on the markets, because hundreds of thousands of gold were used to create companies.
2. a lot of excess in local money.
I strongly believe that such an impact on the exchange rates could also have been done by "fake money". So this could be a third problem for the exchange rates. We had that before.
I already wrote too much about what the problem is.
Solutions.
First, the least complex one, I think that productivity should be decreased by a change in the formula. By doing this, all the above stated problems will be no more, no more excess supply, no more reason for Plato to buy things, no more excess local money.
Second, if the rumours are true and Plato is buying stuff from the market, he should buy local money with gold and only after that he should buy products. I wouldn't do this, it would encourage lazyness, still it would be better than just creating more local money.
Third, final and best option in my opinion: ADD MORE LEVELS to the companies, get it to quality 10, or quality 50. Nobody will have money to create a level 50 company, still nobody got to God of War.
By increasing the number of levels the total number of products on the market will be decreased, so less excess goods.
Also something should be done about making an upgrade of a company more attractive.
20 gold invested in a grain company will get you a return of around 0.50 gold/day, so you will get your 20 gold back in 40 days.
390 gold invested in a quality 5 food company will get you THE SAME RETURN: 0.50 gold/day, so you will get your 390 gold back in more than two years.
If Plato will do something about this, eRepublik economy will have a chance to get back up.
I wrote this article as the guvernor of the National Bank of Romania, romanians needed some explanations about the problems with the exchange rate and also about the problems with the prices dropping and increasing back again.
p.s. vine si traducerea in romana. 🙂
Comments
astept traducerea in romana😁
Great Article !
Plato will go with third because that means extra Gold .
1st is not a solution right now .It will get us back to 1 month ago when to fight with 300 food and 60 damage weps used to cost around 8 Golds.
Plato a murit acum ceva vreme... cu totii ne amintim de asta... Cine stie ce hacker turk ii foloseste acum contul?...
:😁)
interesant, votat!
Cred ca ce se doreste este ca Goldul sa fie chiar Gold .
Adica ridicarea valorii lui in local currency.
Ca efect va scadea si aportul adus de tanking in lupte prin 2 parghii :
-Gold scump (daca sursa Goldului este moneda )
-in Gold 300 health din paine + arme va costa mai putin .
Pentru a doua parghie mai exista problema salariilor care au scazut si ele .Daca se reuseste ca "userul de rand" sa obtina mai multe produse cu aceeasi munca zilnica(sau mai mult Gold din achievements) atunci si impactul lui asupra bataliilor va fi mai mare .
Este greu ce doresti vladb. Asta inseamna ca Plato sa fie o constanta pe piata si astfel poti spune ca modulul economic o sa fie distrus complet. Va fi o lupta constanta intre state si Plato, unde statele or sa doreasca un curs mai ridicat si stabil, cu posibilitatea de a tipari bani, si Plato.
Oricum o dai, modulul economic tot rau a iesit din situatia asta.
4. make WPs consumables. Let people who want to be workers be workers, and those who want to spend lots of RL money buy all the stuff from them
5,6,7,8,9,10. Make a real anti-cheating system and bring back people who stopped fighting to the battlefield.
I agree clawy. Point 5,6,7,8,9 and 10 are esential ((: LOL
The rest...we can discus
@clawy: vorbim despre lucruri evidente? Sau vorbim despre chestii nespuse pana acum. Cred ca adminii stiu cat de important e pentru afacerea lor sa omoare clonele.
Alex, sunt doua tari in non-combat in acest moment, dupa luptele de azi probabil vor mai intra cateva. Acum cat de evident e sau nu, asta e discutabil, cea ce nimeni nu poate contrazice e ca battle logurile si damage-ul efectiv ne sunt ascunse, astfel ca suspiciunile sunt fondate.
Apoi exista cel putin un script postat pe forum care functioneaza fara probleme. Nu conteaza cine l-a facut, de trisat se poate trisa fara probleme. Multi vor sta deoparte din cauza asta.
@clawy: cand Romania era in non-combat... nu prea te interesa. 🙂
Acum brusc suntem interesati. 😃
Partial ai dreptate, dar sa nu facem pe lupii moralisti.
Pai nici acum nu ma intereseaza in mod deosebit. Eu nu mai lupt de cand chestia asta cu firmele, inainte de aia dadeam 2-3 lupte asa din plicitiseala.
Am zis doar ca exemplu de ce distruge economia.
Faza nostima e ca in momentul care a dus la non-combatul vostru a fost o decizie contestata de ambele parti. Modul in care s-a rezolvat ceva atunci a devenit tipic jocului.
clawy si "log-ulrile" donatiilor sunt blocate 🙂 add that to the list.
Agree with Alex. Insa il si contrazic pe Alex: productivitatea era f mica. Trebuie sa te gandesti ca eu guru* cu salariu fair value nu puteam sa-mi cumpar decat paine pt max 5-6 lupte/zi, nici sa mai vb de arme, lucru care nu era in v1. Deci trebuia sa gaseasca metode sa omoare rpd clonele care produc si nu consuma si sa creasca productivitatea. Acum singura problema esta ca productivitatea in sine a crescut exponential pt anumiti indivizi si nu mai este "legata" de labor market fie ea reala sau clone.
Am si pierdut o groaza de timp sa ma gandesc la o solutie: http://forum.erepublik.com/showthread.php/107420-New-Manager-Feature-A-Black-Hole-for-the-economy-amp-solution 😃
PS: $ dropped from 0.02 to 0.013.
"PS: $ dropped from 0.02 to 0.013. "
Grozav ((: Cumpara.
admins are doing that also 🙂 all over the world. whether them or colin lantrip is saving world economy 😁
@all: this is not an article about what admins are doing, it is about solutions.
Cred ca ai dreptate, in plus, s-ar putea reveni si la clasificarea firmelor de raw, asa cum era in v1. Cam tot ce s-a intamplat pe modulul economic in ultima perioada, dupa v2, a fost ilogic, contrar oricarei reguli care guverneaza o economie de piata normala si functionala. Ceva trebuie facut.
sau chiar mai bine solutia 4: ca manager nu ai voie sa lucrezi decat la o singura companie. simplu
Public debate!!!
FP is a must...
But really, a fine article.
Eu m-am gândit la o altă soluţie:
să poţi scoate wellness nelimitat din consumul de food.
Cine ar vrea să dea mai multe sute de mii de damage, probabil că ar face rost de gold oricum (poate şi prin cumpărare), dar acesta ar intra în economie/industrie, şi abia apoi ar ieşi din joc prin boostere/upgrade-uri.
PS: Legat de ultima parte a commentului meu: cred ca asta a fost si intentia adminilor, sa scada costul total de productie, dar a fost facuta fara o analiza in detaliu. Deh... "Drumul spre iad e pavat cu intentii bune"...
@Matreazza: 1. de aia n-am spus ca e o treaba sigur, ci ca e doar la nivel de zvon. Avand in vedere si incasarile Romaniei noaptea... ma gandesc serios daca e zvon sau realitate.
2. Stergerea Ungariei a costat probabil undeva la 10-15.000 gold in HP, adica bani care dispar, banii de food si de weapons se pot invart. Nimic in comparatie cu zecile de mii de firme noi.
In plus noi vorbim de evolutia din ultimele saptamani, nu de ce s-a intamplat acum doua luni.
3. Nimeni nu s-ar angaja la firma ta, atunci productivitatea ti-ar fi omorata, toti lucreaza pentru ei. Solutia e eventual limitarea numarului de firme si asa cum am zis deja... scaderea productivitatii.
4. Din pacate inteleg ca nu e o optiune.
@AC: 2. Era vorba doar de impact la nivelul consumului de gold.
3. Nu vad pe niciunul din zecile sau sutele de jucatori care si-au deschis 1-2 firme, ca sa mai faca un ban, sa fie in stare sa duca o firma pe picioare in conditii normale. Cel putin nu in fata celor experimentati si cu resurse. Ca sa nu mai vorbim de faptul ca asta ar duce la o explozie de salarii, ce ar pune o tensiune foarte mare asupra patronilor si cei ce nu ar avea suficient capital ar falimenta. O reducere a numarului de firme s-ar face in orice caz.
@Matreazza: 2. exact impactul ala ti l-am zis, maxim 10-15.000 gold.
3. cei care si-au deschis firme... lucreaza singuri in ele, de aici faptul ca-si permit sa vanda ieftin, din ce in ce mai ieftin, pana vor realiza ca nu mai scot nimic.
HELP, they do it again! http://www.erepublik.com/en/Russia/law/66252
Bine zici...
votat
nice review
toate cele trei variante pe care le-ai oferit nu sunt fezabile din pacate. totul a pornit de la faptul ca poti lucra la ORICATE companii detii. chiar daca se modifica formula de calcul a productivitatii, companiile alea raman in continuare si vor influenta masiv piata. si de unde aberatia asta sa poti lucra de mai multe ori (chiar daca la companii diferite). jocul asta dintr-un simulator economic/politic/militar, a ajuns un haos. sry dar deja se ajunge la penibil aici...
PS: oricum obiectivul este atins. un consum masiv de gold in final. lol
1 GOLD = 61.69 RON atm
@BogdanM: articolul porneste de la premisa ca adminii nu prea-si schimba deciziile.
Am oferit alte solutii decat revenirea la o situatie anterioara.