America at a Crossroads
Judean Princess
Today I would like to talk about an issue which is of great concern, not only to the nations and individuals involved but to the whole world. Once every few months a momentous shift in geopolitics occurs, and taking advantage of that shift can define the success or failure of everyone from the ordinary two clicker to entire alliances. Looking back in time we can identify these moments, if not easily, then with less difficulty than when we try to do so at the time. Predicting them is something every citizen with a newspaper and the ability to read the news does, but identifying them correctly at the time is very difficult indeed.
One such occasion, for perspective, was the election of Kalleholm as President of Sweden. The election of one more Flashback Sweden member in a small and increasingly less important Northern European country was something that was left unremarked upon by all except the countries neighbours, notably the United Kingdom and Germany. At the time, few expected his actions to lead to the collapse of ATLANTIS, the estrangement of the American and Canadian branches of the oldest alliance, the catastrophic invasion of the USA and the dominance of PEACE and Phoenix in Asia ever since.
That is not to say every major event is caused by a pivotal moment such as this. The invasion and conquest of Spain by France (and subsequent baby boom, invasion and conquest of France by Spain) was a matter of numbers not of a single event turning the tide. Indeed, two enemy countries battering each other isn't even news anymore. The really important events are those which change things, not those who merely extent the existing state of affairs. For this reason Indonesia leaving PEACE was a more important factor in geopolitical terms than the US conquest of Karnataka. It spurred on the members of that dead alliance to reform with new rules and a cut down membership. Sometimes these critical events can lead to huge changes in the world, and if the events are just right, sometimes a single individual can change the course of history.
Right now we are approaching one of these moments. In some ways, it has already happened. The US withdrawal (partial or complete, few people can say for sure, including them) from the EDEN 'brotherhood' might have been inevitable and predictable. Echoing the same concerns raised over a year ago, the US has remade 2009 almost perfectly. The Brolliance reborn (FORTIS Mark 2), EDEN slowly being whittled down in Europe by emerging powers, a new super-power to be feared (this time it's Poland): its almost a perfect recreation of past events.
The USA is politically and culturally very important. As one of the oldest nations in the EDEN string of alliances, it represents them as much as Indonesia represent Phoenix. As an economic power, it is unrivalled. It wrings an efficiency out of its regions that is only found in a handful of countries. Others have more income, but per capita the USA ranks with Russia, and the other english speaking countries as a cut above the rest. Culturally it has survived a huge invasion and represents the tenacity of ATLANTIS-EDEN. It is a powerful country, and although EDEN are perhaps justified to complain that it's damage won't be missed (since it was never there to start with) the alliance as a whole will be much weaker without it. Region swapping through Poland and Spain is one thing. Roughnecking it through Russia or Turkey with formidable MPPs stacked against them is another thing entirely.
The USA has two unfavourable choices, and one impossible one now. Its entirely possible that it will once again emerge on top- it is one of the most resiliant countries in eRep after all. Its choices are: Attempt to join Phoenix; Attempt to survive against EDEN and Phoenix; Attempt to reconcile its position with EDEN. I will leave the reader to try and work out what is unfavourable and what is impossible. Regardless of decisions made, the USA will be in a tough position. Like everyone else they wait for V2, hoping to take advantage out of the changes. Their large and computer literate population base may give them an edge here, but like everything else it's guesswork.
In my opinion, their best choice would be to join Phoenix. Phoenix may dislike them, but the chance of securing Asia completely against EDEN would be irresistable. That said, I also think this the least likely thing to happen. The USA hates being told what to do, and the hierarchy of Phoenix wouldn't allow them the freedom they have now as a quasi-independent alliance. They could continue to work with EDEN, but again after such a public withdrawal I would imagine this will be confined to the kind of informal arrangements we saw during the US invasion rather than any kind of formal arrangement. The most likely situation now is the establishment of the USA as an independent power, which has a primary focus East not West. This has massive implications for the EDEN powers, who perhaps hope for USA to provide the bulk of pressure on the United Kingdom, France and so on in the future.
The Future of the eUS?
As well, we must remember that the USA and Canada are almost inseparable allies, and so it's entirely possible that whatever decision the USA makes, the Canadians might also follow suit. This could result in a new Brolliance with a newly reborn eSouth Africa, and eAustralia (who have both expressed interest in such a pact) included. This alliance would possess almost half of the New World’s titanium (provided eSA reclaimed all of the relevant regions) and would certainly be a force to be reckoned with.
As well, if the USA joins Phoenix (an act that would leave Canada the only EDEN nation in North America), then Canada would join as well, giving Phoenix hegemony over the whole Western Hemisphere. All the more reason for Phoenix to court the USA.
Now I am of course not saying that either alliance is better based off any opinion I have, but looking at the whole situation from a practical point of view, the US would benefit most from joining Phoenix given the fact that the other options would result in annihiliation (going it alone) or the same old conflicts continuing on (EDEN). When I look at these options, they stand to gain the most from Phoenix.
Identifying moments that change the world is difficult. However in my opinion one is fast approaching. The decision from EDEN countries on how to deal with the USA could very well divide the alliance. One EDEN coup has already happened. The next could destroy EDEN forever. This has implications for both alliances, as Phoenix cannot exist without something to fight. Poland is very nearly as powerful as all of the rest of the remaining parts of EDEN together. Old powers such as Sweden are fading somewhat. The pivotal moment, when it comes, will be recognisable not by itself, but by the effect it has on the attitudes of others. If you want to know who has their hands on the lever, ask those who supposedly plotted the downfall of the USA with EDEN. Because they are the true powers in EDEN. Not Country Presidents or elected officials, but shadowy men in shadowy rooms.
Some people are just plain Evil…
Comments
FIRST OMG
Voted, a very interesting article and perspective.
3rd, very nice point of view
It would be much more interesting if we had 3 sides: Phoenix, EDEN and USA - like in Starcraft, Good, Bad & Ugly and so on.
Like the Starcraft mention.
But lets be honest, from a long term Canadian Congressmen Canada was really hostile to the idea of joining PEACE PRIOR to being wiped off the map... Canada will never be allied with Hungary, not without a PTO or a MAJOR change in their policies.
I like how the last line wraps in with the Phoenix part.
Great article! 😁
voted.) cool
It's a nice article that seems difficult to picture when you are new in the eWorld. Let's see how this finally ends because nobody can predict the future.
Revise JP dammit...your unbanned frm #eSingapore btw
Good article
Voted
Judean Princess, more pictures, please.
Excellent perspective. I'm almost in full agreement with your points. There is a bit much unfounded optimism floating around now in the eUSA, without much pragmatism to back it up. Change will come.
Two things stuck out in that article as false in my eyes(out of the parts that I actually read)....
1. eUSA battle damage won't be missed because it wasn't there to begin with....that has got to be the silliest thing that i have ever heard. The eUS has put out upwaqrds of 2.5 millions points of battle damage in battles. We usually output Poland in battles, and they have more citizens than anyone.
2. The eUS doesn't like to take orders....once again, wrong. We can take orders just fine, it's that we have a problem with taking orders that only serves one or two EDEN alliance members agenda's, and goes against what EDEN originally stood for. That is where the problem of taking orders came in.
😘
VEry good article Judean Princess.
very interesting perspectives. v^s
wowzers
That EDEN symbol really should be redrawn now as a tree in Autumn with some of its leaves having fallen off.
really good analises*...
J.P. - really excellent editorial, well written. The changes of the eUSA joining Phoenix are about as good as me eating a hamster sandwich for lunch. the eUSA's objective should be to develop the economic and military punching power of the Brolliance. We stand for something special: equality, mutual support and sacrifice and, most importantly, friendship. Three weeks of europeans trolling US articles insulting us pales in significance to the Months and Months of trolling from Phoenix operatives. They stand for domination of the eRepublik world. We stand for truth, justice and having a good time. To borrow the words of Churchill (with apologies to Phoenix lapdog eUK) "...whatever the cost may be,
we shall fight on the beaches,
we shall fight on the landing grounds,
we shall fight in the fields and in the streets,
we shall fight in the hills;
we shall never surrender..."
Hail the Brolliance, Hail our Band of Brothers.
😃
Indonesia and Usa in same alliance = impossible
great article
cute friends...
Great read. This is becoming one of my favorite papers.
I stopped reading after "USA should join Phoenix". NO NO NO NO NO we should not! Hell no! Omg I just vomited alittle thinking of that idea.
Goooooooooooood
Joining PHOENIX is definitely NOT the answer. But a third alliance built around English-speaking countries could be the answer. That is why it is a moral and practical imperative for all eUSA citizens to go fight to defend Western Australia today. We are being tested. Our will and resolve are being challenged. Today is the day, the time is now.
Great article
The US will never join Phoenix. Their overall goals do not match with ours. We refuse to be pawns to one or two alliance members. Why would we trade a Polish/Spanish rule to a Hungarian/Russian rule?
We will still work with EDEN to fight Phoenix, and will continue to sign MPPs with the EDEN nations that will sign with us - just not Poland or Spain. Plotting our destruction kind of puts a damper on that relationship.
join Phoenix? boo hiss, begone
Nice written article although i disagree with eUS ever joining phoenix. We stand for everything that phoenix is not and if we did end up joining with them, I'd have to leave for another country.
voted.
even it's way too long 🙂
Some things can't happen *even if* there were good strategic reasons. The USA being allied with Russia, Hungary, Serbia, Indonesia, and Brazil is certainly one of them.
Very interesting analysis, the best read all day.
"EDEN are perhaps justified to complain that it's damage won't be missed (since it was never there to start with) the alliance as a whole will be much "
The eUSA has kicked ass all over the world ... for EDEN. We were given dozens of stupid jobs and we did them well. For EDEN. But the eUSA's goals were never important to EDEN.
We will never join Phoenix. If every current player quit the game, and we had completely new players ... the memories would still linger.
The game would be much better with more and smaller alliances.
Who's defending Australia?
Beautifull girls
Starcraft is a work of art - incredibly hard to achieve a balance of three forces with differences.
A truly three-alliance system would be highly instable relative to a two-alliance system because of the possibility of shifting negotiations (2 against a 3rd) and the unpredictability of the actions of the third party in any conflict.
Very nice article,
VnS...
Judean Princess
i was always have respect for USA!!!
USA seen that EDEN is failamxx then they decited to leave it 😁
so USA join PNX is beter for all 😃
PS. Judean Princess
do you wanna eMarriage for me?? 😛PP
join Phoenix 😃
"[USA]It is a powerful country, and although EDEN are perhaps justified to complain that it's damage won't be missed (since it was never there to start with) the alliance as a whole will be much weaker without it."
Contradict yourself there.
This article is ripe with speculation based in extremely questionable understanding of current geopolitics.
Good article, well done!
voted, wall of text 😛
Join Phoenix?
I really hate you stupid "princes" ..
Surprisingly good read, Voted/Subed
I guess PHX will call USA if we want to fall apart.
[/troll]
It would be so much fun to see iranians and americans working together as a team. 😘
Interesting article and I agree with almost everything except this: "eUSA battle damage won't be missed because it wasn't there to begin with" and this "The eUS doesn't like to take orders". Preston Sage explained why these points are wrong.
Do it.
vote!
vote
voted!